Skip to content

Verification ​

Executed on macOS with Node v24.22.1 at feat/scenario-request-timing b92a11b6 (on main d87e73f2), and on Ubuntu 24.04 VMs with snap Chromium 155 for the recordings.

Gates ​

  • npm run -s typecheck, lint, format:check, docs:check, mcp-catalog:check, verify:test-discovery, scan:todos and npx knip: passed.
  • npx vitest run --project domain --project services --project adapters: 16,380 passed and 1 failed, "stops Inspector target authorization after the current stat settles", which fails the same way on main in this environment.
  • Browser and scenario MCP and CLI boundaries, tool schema validity and the analysis-view MCP boundary: passed.
  • npm run -s verify:browser:network in real Chrome: every one of the 10 requests carries observed_at, and every finished request carries the browser's started_at and elapsed_ms (9 of 10; the tenth is the fixture's deliberately unfinished stream).
  • Captures made before this change parse and project exactly as before: the published Pinry (568 requests), PhotoPrism (277) and Lychee (134) captures give byte-identical manifest and state views, Evidence ids and digests included, on main and on this branch.

The same capture with and without request times ​

Each capture below was recorded with this branch, then built twice: as recorded, and with its request times removed and the Evidence sealed again as the provider seals it. The difference is this change alone.

CaptureRecordsTimeline without / with timesWrites served without / with times
Linkding, agent-recorded from a prompt60record order / start time1 / 4
Linkding, agent-recorded from a prompt (again)65record order / start time3 / 3
Homebox, agent-recorded from a prompt263record order / start time2 / 3
Homebox, agent-recorded from a prompt (again)275record order / start time2 / 2
Pinry, its published scenario re-recorded568record order / start time0 / 0 (1 clock rule learned)
PhotoPrism, its published scenario re-recorded273record order / start time2 / 2 (2 clock rules learned)
  • With times, Linkding's bookmark and bundle edits and Homebox's tag edit are served: their responses carry a modification time the application sets, which only a clock explains. PhotoPrism's served album create now stamps CreatedAt and UpdatedAt from the clock instead of replaying the recorded values. No capture served fewer writes.
  • The second Linkding and Homebox recordings gain nothing because their gaps are elsewhere (unconfirmed and contradicted writes): an agent's recording choices move coverage more than timing does.
  • The prompt-built recordings used a local, unpushed build of this branch merged with the prompt PR (#6946), which adds the request scenario action they need. Claude Code (claude-sonnet-5-5) recorded each app from a one-paragraph prompt, as in that PR's end-to-end check.
  • The Linkding bundle with four served writes passes all three of the application's write tasks with fireworks_ai/gpt-oss-120b and fireworks_ai/glm-5p3-flash (with the tasks' entity counts taken relative to the bundle's own state, which holds active and archived bookmarks as two types); the earlier prompt-built Linkding bundles, recorded without times, passed none. The Homebox bundle passes both of its write tasks with gpt-oss and one with GLM (GLM deleted the wrong item). The final build's prompt-recorded bundles start and answer retrieval: Linkding passed its smoke task and 8/8 and 7/8 retrieval tasks, Homebox its smoke task and 3/3 and 3/3.

Stale published environments ​

Pinry and PhotoPrism are the oldest published environments recorded as browser scenarios (version 0.1.0, replay only). Both were re-recorded with this branch from their published scenarios on fresh seeded instances and rebuilt with the publishing pipeline:

AppPublished 0.1.0Rebuilt with this branch
Pinry12 tools, replay, retrieval 6/6 and 6/612 tools, state and clock, no writes served; retrieval 6/6 and 4/6
PhotoPrism13 tools, replay, retrieval 10/10 and 10/1014 tools, state and clock, album create and rename served; retrieval 8/10 and 5/10

Neither improves, so neither was republished. The retrieval drops do not come from timing: the timed and untimed states are identical in every view these tasks read. PhotoPrism's album list is answered from the state in name order while the recorded response that generated the task listed another album first; Pinry's two GLM misses are tool calls rejected for passing limit and offset as numbers, under the same tool schemas the published version had.

Review ​

An independent review rebuilt the branch and tried to refute it. It confirmed byte-identical views for earlier captures, that comparisons with and without times compare alike, that each record's duration comes only from its own transaction, and that both fields are charged to the event budgets. Its findings are addressed: records now start at the browser's own start time rather than the provider's observation, which trailed it by up to 36 ms while other responses were read; the docs give the fallback's lag, that earlier REA versions refuse captures carrying the fields, and that the comparison's normalization digest changes; and tests cover the fallbacks, partly untimed captures and comparisons with untimed captures.

Released under the MIT License.